Eager to identify the best Weller bourbon but short on time or resources? Our definitive Weller bourbon review is just the shortcut you need.
We’ve taste-tested, solving the “Which Weller bourbon is best?” conundrum.
From the elusive Full Proof to the unassuming Special Reserve, we’ve done the heavy siping for you.
Whether a seasoned aficionado or a whiskey newbie, our guide will help you navigate the different Weller bourbons and pinpoint your perfect pour.
Stay tuned for our thorough ranking and discover the #1 Weller bourbon without ever lifting a glass.
The Best Weller Bourbon in 2023
The crown for the Best Weller Bourbon in 2023 goes deservedly to William Larue Weller.
As part of the Buffalo Trace Antique Collection, this bourbon impresses with its uncut, unfiltered, barrel-proof strength and well-aged lineage.
Named after the bourbon pioneer who first introduced wheat to the mash bill, this bourbon typically clocks in at an ABV above 60%, offering an intoxicating dance of rich, complex flavors. It unfolds on the palate with waves of caramel, dried fruit, and baking spices, followed by an enduring, warming finish.
The bouquet is a symphony of toasted oak, dark chocolate, and vanilla, adding depth to the drinking experience. Though its price may be steep due to its age (usually over 12 years) and rarity, the unparalleled taste and sophistication of William Larue Weller make it a justifiable indulgence.
In 2023, for those seeking the epitome of wheated bourbon, William Larue Weller stands unmatched.
6 More Weller Bourbons Ranked
In ranking these bourbons, our primary focus was on flavor and overall value.
Flavor because, ultimately, the taste is what truly defines a great bourbon.
Value, because a top-notch bourbon that breaks the bank can hardly be considered a sensible choice for most.
Yet, it’s important to remember that all Weller expressions are excellent in their own right.
Each brings a unique character to the table, appealing to different palates and preferences. So, whether you’re a seasoned connoisseur or just starting your bourbon journey, there’s a Weller bourbon waiting to captivate your senses.
2. Weller 12 Year
MSRP: $40; Realistic Price: $300-400
Our Bourbon Inspector Insiders love Weller 12 for its deep and complex flavor profile. Its twelve-year journey in oak barrels imparts a rich tapestry of flavors, melding sweet caramel and fruit with a sturdy backbone of oak.
From the survey results, it’s evident that our Insiders aren’t alone in their praise. This expression was heralded as the best-tasting Weller, with many Insiders actively hunting for this bottle.
Despite the demand making it a bit elusive, the pursuit of the Weller 12 is a testament to its quality and highly respected standing in the bourbon community. Its balance of approachability and complexity has endeared it to seasoned enthusiasts and newcomers alike, underscoring the universal appeal of this exceptional bourbon.
With a balanced 45% ABV, the Weller 12 Year walks the line between approachable and complex, making it a favorite among both seasoned enthusiasts and newcomers alike.
3. Weller Antique 107
MSRP: $50; Realistic Price: $100-150
Carrying a robust 107 proof, Weller Antique 107 amplifies the inherent sweetness of bourbon with potent notes of corn, vanilla, and warming spice.
This is not a bourbon that will be lost on your palate; it proudly announces its presence with every sip. The Antique 107 holds its own as a fantastic representation of the Weller brand, blending quality and affordability.
The Bourbon Inspector Insiders echoed these sentiments, voting it as the best value Weller at realistic retail prices. Although it carries a slightly higher proof, it’s a testament to the skillful balance of flavor and strength that makes this expression a fan favorite.
The Antique 107, with its blend of affordability and quality, is considered the best value Weller by our Insiders. It carries a robust profile that justifies its popularity and price in the secondary market.
Another significant advantage is its relative availability. It’s generally easier to find on shelves than most other Weller expressions, making it a realistic and rewarding option for bourbon enthusiasts looking to enjoy a taste of the Weller brand without having to go on an extensive hunt.
4. Weller Full Proof
MSRP: $50; Realistic Price: $500-1000
As the uncut, unfiltered heavyweight of the Weller family, Full Proof offers a full-throttle bourbon experience. Its 57% ABV packs a punch but remains surprisingly balanced and complex. The palate is robust, delivering generous layers of caramel, toasted oak, and dark fruits.
Despite its strength, it maintains a surprising balance, a testament to Weller’s skilled craftsmanship. While Full Proof does command a higher price in the secondary market, it provides an exceptional tasting experience that many Bourbon Inspector Insiders believe to be worth the investment.
The combination of its unique character and complexity means it continues to be a highly sought-after bottle within the bourbon community.
5. Weller Special Reserve
MSRP: $25; Realistic Price: $50-200
Weller Special Reserve may be considered the gateway to the Weller line, but that doesn’t diminish its merit. This expression shines with its classic wheated bourbon sweetness, coupled with gentle notes of caramel and fruit.
With an ABV of 45%, it’s not overly intimidating, making it the perfect starting point for those looking to explore the brand. While it may not be the top target for Bourbon Inspector Insiders, they agree it’s a quality bourbon that deserves its praise, making it a solid daily sipper or an introduction to the Weller range.
6. Weller Single Barrel
MSRP: N/A; Realistic Price: $350-1500
The allure of the Weller Single Barrel lies in its individuality. Each barrel offers a unique tasting experience, typically featuring a harmonious mix of sweetness, enhanced oak, and spice. Though it doesn’t seem to be a primary target among Bourbon Inspector Insiders, its distinct character and balance between price and quality make it a prized find among bourbon enthusiasts who appreciate the thrill of the hunt and the reward of a unique tasting experience.
7. Weller C.Y.P.B. (Craft Your Perfect Bourbon)
MSRP: $50; Realistic Price: $400-1300
The Weller C.Y.P.B. holds a unique spot within the Weller lineup. This expression was crafted from crowd-sourced input, promising an enjoyable tasting experience tailored to popular demand. Yet, despite its bespoke nature, it doesn’t appear to be a priority among the Bourbon Inspector Insiders, perhaps due to its higher price point and limited availability. However, for those seeking a bourbon crafted by the people, and for the people, this is a great choice.
This ranking aligns with the votes and recommendations from Bourbon Inspector Insiders, proving the consistent appeal and reputation of Weller Bourbons.
Pick the Right Weller Bourbon For You
Every expression of Weller is good.
But if we had to pick our #1, it’s definitely William Larue Weller.
But since that will likely be out 99% of peoples’ price range…including mine…here are the other best Weller bourbons by category:
- Cheapest: Weller Special Reserve
- Best Value: Weller Antique 107
- Best Tasting: William Larue Weller
- Most Overrated: Weller Full C.Y.P.B.
Hunter Branch is the Founder and Director of Editorial for Bourbon Inspector. He has been writing about and professionally reviewing bourbon since 2020 (and has been drinking it for much longer). He’s been able to interview big names in the bourbon industry like Trey Zoeller from Jefferson’s Bourbon and his work has been featured in publications like TastingTable, Mashed, and more.