Old Potrero Hotaling’s Bottled-in-Bond Rye Whiskey Review

Distillery: Old Potero—San Francisco, CA

Proof: 100.0 (50.0% ABV)

Age: Thirteen Years

Mashbill: 100% Malted Rye

MSRP: $200

---

A Bonded Testament to Craftmanship, Time, Tenacity

In a city defined by reinvention, Old Potrero is firmly rooted in the origins of American whiskey. Produced by Hotaling & Co. in San Francisco, Old Potrero was among the earliest brands to reintroduce 100% malted rye whiskey to the U.S. whiskey market. That history continues with the release of Old Potrero Hotaling’s Bottled-in-Bond Rye—an expression that aims to honor both the whiskey’s heritage and the resilience of the distillery’s namesake.

This release commemorates the 1906 San Francisco earthquake and fire that leveled much of the city—except Hotaling’s warehouse, which miraculously remained standing. The surviving structure became symbolic, causing on journalist to write, “If, as they say, God spanked the town for being over-frisky, why did He burn the churches down and spare Hotaling’s whiskey?”

Distilled entirely from 100% malted rye and aged for thirteen years, this 2025 Bottled-in-Bond release adheres to the letter of the Bottled-in-Bond Act while serving to a deeper sense of purpose—showcasing what malted rye can achieve with long-term aging.

Old Potrero Hotaling’s Bottled-in-Bond Rye Whiskey Review: Tasting Notes

Nose – 4.4/5

The Nose is assertive yet refined.  Aromas of oak sawdust and damp sweet earth create a marvelous base, while notes of caramel and browned butter lend a sweetness and richness. A soft undercurrent of dried orchard fruit rounds out the experience—fruit-forward but grounded.

Palate – 4.6/5

The Palate begins with a dense, oily mouthfeel—this whiskey was made to linger. Flavors of salted butter and dark cacao nibs unfold slowly, joined by sweet mint and a touch of toasted malt. It’s elegant, not showy, and full of character without bitterness.

Finish – 4.6/5

The Finish is very long and balanced. Sweet oak and a deep, earthy spice settle in first, followed by a slow warmth and just a touch of tangy brightness at the very end. It’s one of those rare finishes that doesn’t dominate the pour—but it will be long remembered.

Value – 4/5

At $200, Old Potrero Hotaling’s Bottled-in-Bond Rye is priced firmly in the premium category.  While that number will feel steep for some, the age, rarity, and quality in this release justify the price tag. It’s not an everyday bottle—it’s a statement bottle.  One meant to be opened with intention and celebration.

For fans of malted rye or bonded whiskey, this release is a high-water mark. And for those looking to understand what “heritage craftmanship” really means–this is the definition.

Old Potrero Hotaling’s Bottled-in-Bond Rye Whiskey Review: The Verdict

Old Potrero Hotaling’s Bottled-in-Bond Rye Whiskey is a masterclass in patience. From its commitment to 100% malted rye to its thirteen years in barrel and its thoughtful homage to San Franciso’s tenacious spirit, this bottle is more than a curiosity.

For fans of malted rye or bonded whiskey, this release is a high-water mark. And for those looking to understand what “heritage craftmanship” really means–this is the definition. Shop here.

Verdict – 4.2/5

We score each bourbon based on nose, palate, finish, and value.

Scoring System:

• Platinum – 4.5 – 5
• Gold – 4 – 4.5
• Silver – 3 – 4
• Bronze – <3